… my obsession with Survivor continues to intensify. And I couldn’t help but think the other day about how some of the weakest seasons of the show all pretty much had one or two aspects that pretty much spoiled the whole thing. So here’s how some of my least favorite seasons could have been sooooo much better.
Pearl Islands: The horrible Outcasts twist. Why did this happen? At least the whole Redemption Island twist never changed the final outcome of a season (aka: the winner). Now, this season is generally considered one of the five best, but I’d absolutely put in the bottom five based on how painfully stupid this twist was. The cast is absolutely awesome, and I would have loved to see how things would have gone in a 5-5 post-merge situation. Had potential to be at least a top ten season for me, if not for the stupid Outcasts.
Cook Islands: The Hidden Immunity Idol should never have been able to be played after the reading of the votes. Either that, or it should never have existed. Period. Yul having it was too much power and him being voted out was practically impossible before the final five. Now I’m not sure how the season would have turned out otherwise, because the Aitu 4 were just so irresistible to root for, and post-merge Raro was filled with some of the worst and least likable players of all-time. Come to think of it actually, either way: this season was probably doomed from the start, and it’s probably better that it turned out the way that it did. Also, Panama: Exile Island (the season before CI) had this same problem with Terry Deitz having way too much power because of his HII. The difference though, is that that guy was tanked out and won five immunities anyway, and by the time he was finally voted out, the HII had only moved him up from fourth place, to third. No big loss, except maybe that Cirie went home in fourth.
Fans vs Favorites: Better casting for the Fans. I mean seriously, this season is so clearly rigged in the favor of the Favorites. Not only have they played before, but they’re also playing against one of the stupidest tribes ever on Survivor. Pathetic.
Samoa: Could have perhaps been the greatest season of all-time. This cast is so excellent. The trouble is Russell fucking Hantz. Never has one person ever dominated a single season’s edit, the way Russell did in Samoa. In fact, from the beginning, all we ever saw was Foa Foa, despite getting absolutely demolished pre-merge, and we never got to know Galu. So post-merge, when Foa Foa returns from an 8-4 disadvantage (thanks entirely to Russell), it doesn’t even matter because the only person we actually know IS Russell. Too bad, between the cast, the total self-destruction of Galu, the big-time strategy and a MUCH subtler presence of Russell, this could have been SO great. But, sadly, the Worst-Edit-in-Survivor-History Award goes to Samoa.
Heroes vs Villains: Now this isn’t really one of my least favorites, but what holds it back is the fact that Russell had the unfair advantage of going into the game with no one being able to see Samoa. Flash-back: season 8, All-Stars. Boston Rob removes Rob Cesternino from the game IMMEDIATELY, because he was the only player who could give BR a run for his money. Okay, back to HvV: Samoa hasn’t even aired yet while HvV is being filmed, and no one has a clue who Russell is or what kind of game he played. But everyone else is familiar with each other. Number one: just not fair. Number two: BR would have kicked his ass out of there so fast. Changed the outcome of the whole season.
Redemption Island/South Pacific: Now, I’m most definitely one of the many people who believe that RI is the absolute worst of all Survivor seasons. I don’t even think it could have been saved the way South Pacific (they both share the exact same twists) could have been, mainly because RI has one one of the stupidest casts ever. So onto SP: eliminate the Redemption Island twist and the two returning players (and maybe Brandon Hantz), and this cast could have given us one of the best seasons ever. But no, producers are so obsessed with returning players and keeping them around as long as possible, that actual game-play, great new players, reward challenges, and fair edits come second to that.
One World: THE stupidest cast of all-time, and there’s no competition. Yet again, the major flaw here is casting a bunch of mindless sheep.




